of the refurrection of Chrift came forth, as it immediately did; when it was publicly afferted by his difciples, and made the ground and bafis of their preaching in his name, and collecting followers to his religion, the Jews had not the body to produce but were obliged to meet the teftimony of the apoftles by an answer, not containing indeed any impoffibility in itself, but abfolutely inconfiftent with the supposition of their integrity; that is, in other words, inconfiftent with the fuppofition, which would refolve their conduct into enthusiasm. CHAP. CHAP. IX. The Propagation of Chriflianity. IN this argument, the first confideration is the fact; in what degree, within what time, and to what extent, Christianity actually was propagated. The accounts of the matter, which can be collected from our books, are as follow: A few days after Chrift's disappearance out of the world, we find an affembly of difciples at Jerufalem, to the number of “ about one hundred and twenty*;" which hundred and twenty were, probably, a little affociation of believers, met together, not merely as believers in Chrift, but as perfonally connected with the apoftles, and with one another. Whatever was the number of be VOL. II. *Acts i. 5. P lievers lievers then in Jerufalem, we have no reasort. to be surprised that fo fmall a company fhould affemble; for there is no proof that the followers of Chrift were yet formed into a fociety, that the fociety was reduced into any order, that it was at this time even underfood, that a new religion (in the fenfe which that term conveys to us) was to be fet up in the world, or how the profeffors of that religion were to be diftinguished from the rest of mankind. The death of Christ had left, we may suppose, the generality of his difciples in great doubt, both as to what they were to do, and concerning what was to follow. This meeting was held, as we have already faid, a few days after Chrift's afcenfion; for, ten days after that event was the day of pentecoft, when, as our history relates, upon a fignal difplay of divine agency attending the perfons of the apoftles, there were added to the fociety "about *Acts ii. I three three thousand fouls." But here, it is not, We read in the fourth † chapter of the Acts, that, foon after this, "the number of the men," i. e. of the fociety openly profeffing their belief in Chrift, " was about five thousand." So that here is an increase of two thousand within a very fhort time. And it is probable that there were many, + Verfe 4. * Acts ii. 41. P 2 both both now and afterwards, who, although they believed in Chrift, did not think it neceffary to join themselves to this fociety; or who waited to fee what was likely to become of it. Gamaliel, whofe advice to the Jewish council is recorded Acts iv. 34, appears to have been of this defcription; perhaps Nicodemus, and perhaps alfo Joseph of Arimathea. This clafs of men, their character and their rank, are likewife pointed out by St. John, in the twelfth chapter of his gofpel: "Nevertheless among the chief rulers alfo many believed on him; but because of the Pharifees they did not confefs him, left they should be put out of the fynagogue for they loved the praise of men more than the praife of God." Perfons fuch as thefe, might admit the miracles. of Chrift, without being immediately convinced that they were under obligation to make a public profeffion of Christianity, at the risk of all that was dear to them in life, and even of life itself*. Christianity, * "Befide those who profeffed, and those who rejected and oppofed Christianity, there were, in all probability, |